«
»

Thursday 30 April 2009

thousands dead, nothing said

yeah, get the fuck out

The last British troops are on their way out of Iraq, quitting Basra in the southeast of the country.

I have been wanting Britain to get out of Iraq since it first got into the place. But somehow I am managing to contain my delight.

The UK forces have now handed control of Basra over… to the US. It is an imperial game of pass-the-parcel.

Gordon Brown has had a word or two to say. Here he is, from the Number 10 website.

Today we open the next chapter in our relations, a chapter which I preface with my deep respect and appreciation for Iraq’s achievements and my gratitude to Britain’s armed forces who have made such a lasting contribution.

What kind of lasting contribution?

Well, according to Iraq Body Count, 3,845 ordinary Iraqis have died violent deaths in the Basra area since the Iraq war began. Yeah, that should last.

The IBC map shows how the Basra deaths fit into a far higher total of around 100,000 across 12 of Iraq’s 18 provinces. Other estimates, such as those published in the Lancet medical journal, are higher still.

IBC map

The Lancet put the death toll at 655,000 in 2006. Extrapolating the figures to today would put the Iraqi deaths at well over a million. The deaths figure for Basra would be many times higher than the IBC numbers.

Here’s a bit more from Gordon:

Today Iraq is a success story. We owe much of that to the efforts of British troops. Our mission has not always been an easy one, many have said that we would fail.

He must have forgotten to give his condolences.

But Brown has remembered the far smaller number of UK casualties.

A memorial in Basra, honouring the British service men and women who lost their lives in Iraq would be “preserved for ever”.

The reason the Iraqi death figures come from the Lancet and Iraq Body Count is that the occupying forces have refused to keep count or ever list the names of Iraqis who have died as a result of the US/UK war. In the Brown book of condolence you get a name and a memory if you’re British. If you’re Iraqi, you don’t.

We do know the name of one Iraqi man who died in Basra, though.Baha Mousa post mortem pic Hotel worker Baha Mousa was beaten to death by British soldiers. A post-mortem revealed 93 separate injuries on his body. It took five years for the Ministry of Defence to come up with an apology and compensation.

There has been no apology – or even acknowledgement – for the rest of the IBC’s estimated 3,854 deaths in Basra, let alone the many more who have died according to the Lancet’s scientific study. Yet each of those people will be terribly missed by their family and friends, just as Baha Mousa is missed by his wife and two young sons.

The Downing Street statement has something far more important to report, however.

The PM said there was now a clear message for companies worldwide: “Iraq is open for business.”

Oh yes.

Mr Brown said the UK would begin negotiations with Iraq on investment promotion.

Iraq – now a fine investment opportunity for British capital. There’s a success story for you.

posted by red at 11:55 pm in anti-war | 2 comments
Tags: , , ,

2 comments

  1. Queenie wrote:

    My understanding of Iraq Body Count is that it seems to exist solely to minimise the death stats. Whether useful idiots or deliberately coopted, I’m not sure. Every other estimate has been closer to a million.

    Sadly I have no links to back this up right now and am therefore just spouting hot air, so feel free to disregard everything I say.

    Oh no, hang on, there’s this

    Make of it what you will.

    Back to your point though: yes, it’s been a lovely war for business. Not so much for the collateral damage. I can’t believe the words “open for business” were actually used in the statement. Good heavens.

    1 May 2009 at 1:32pm
  2. red wrote:

    Yes you are right. On previous posts elsewhere, I have used the Lancet’s figures, which put the 2006 figure at 655,000 Iraqi deaths. That is estimated to be more than a million if the numbers are extrapolated to today.

    That is a very good critique from Media Lens of the problems with the IBC figures, which I had pulled up on a search for Basra.

    Obviously I don’t want to minimise the Iraqi casualties. I am going to edit the post now, to highlight the Lancet figures, which I referred to but didn’t quote or link.

    *switches critical faculties back on*

    Lots of thanks Queenie.

    UPDATE: edit done.

    1 May 2009 at 1:49pm

go on, say something

Drop your comment in the box below. You can't ping. Mainly because I don't know what it is.

:

:


«
»